Connect with us

Special Reports

ADC questions Tinubu’s reliance on World Bank over fuel subsidy removal

Published

on

“Since when did the economic recommendations of an international financial institution become instructions that a sovereign government must obey, regardless of the suffering they could inflict on its citizens?”

The National Publicity Secretary of the African Democratic Congress (ADC), Bolaji Abdullahi, has questioned President Bola Tinubu’s handling of the fuel subsidy removal, accusing his administration of prioritising the World Bank’s recommendations over Nigerians’ welfare.

He raised the concerns in an opinion article titled ‘Who Governs Nigeria, Tinubu or the World Bank?’ published on his X handle on Friday.

Mr Tinubu announced the removal of the petrol subsidy on 29 May 2023, shortly after taking the oath of office as Nigeria’s 16th President.

In his inaugural address at Eagle Square, Abuja, he declared, “The fuel subsidy is gone,” explaining that the 2023 budget made no provision for subsidy payments beyond June.

He said the funds would instead be redirected towards infrastructure, education, healthcare and job creation. The announcement immediately triggered an increase in petrol prices and raised concerns about the cost of living.

Mr Abdullahi was reacting to comments by former Lagos State Governor Babatunde Fashola, who defended the removal of the fuel subsidy during an interview on Channels Television’s Politics Today on Tuesday.

Mr Fashola argued that the decision was influenced by the country’s financial circumstances and the World Bank’s position, which, he said, indicated that Nigeria would no longer receive financing if it continued to fund the petrol subsidy.

The former governor also cited provisions of the Petroleum Industry Act (PIA), which established a market-based framework for petroleum product pricing, and questioned the financial sustainability of proposals to restore the subsidy.

However, Mr Abdullahi said the former governor’s explanation raised questions about the independence of the Tinubu administration’s economic decisions.

He argued that international financial institutions could offer policy recommendations but should not determine how Nigeria manages its economy.

The ADC spokesperson said the World Bank’s recommendations should be considered alongside the country’s circumstances, not treated as binding instructions.

He wrote, “Since when did the economic recommendations of an international financial institution become instructions that a sovereign government must obey, regardless of the suffering they could inflict on its citizens?”

Mr Abdullahi also questioned whether the president had adequately considered alternatives before implementing the policy, arguing that the Nigerian government remained responsible for its consequences.

“International institutions are entitled to offer recommendations. They are not elected to govern Nigeria. The President is,” he said.

Beyond the World Bank’s involvement, Mr Abdullahi challenged Mr Fashola’s reliance on the Petroleum Industry Act to justify removing the fuel subsidy.

He argued that laws should serve citizens’ interests and should be reviewed when their implementation undermines public welfare.

The ADC spokesperson maintained that the legislation should not prevent the government from considering measures that could make petroleum products more affordable.

He said the PIA, which was passed in August 2021, had remained before the National Assembly for several years before its eventual passage because of concerns about some of its provisions.

Mr Abdullahi, however, argued that the same legislation contained provisions that could support the ADC’s proposed alternative to the current fuel pricing arrangement.

He specifically cited Section 109 of the Act, which provides for a Domestic Crude Supply Obligation (DCSO), requiring crude oil producers to dedicate specified volumes of crude oil towards supplying domestic refineries.

The provision also empowers the Nigerian Upstream Petroleum Regulatory Commission (NUPRC) to issue regulations and guidelines for enforcing the obligation.

According to Mr Abdullahi, the provision allows the government to support local refineries through domestic crude supply arrangements rather than relying entirely on imported petroleum products.

He said the ADC and its presidential candidate, Atiku Abubakar, were proposing a production subsidy that would use domestic refining capacity to reduce the cost of petroleum products.

“The question then is: Why has this administration failed to enforce that aspect of the law and use it as a lever to support local refineries so they can deliver cheaper fuel to Nigerians?” he asked.

However, Section 109 also stipulates that domestic crude oil supplies should generally operate on a willing-supplier, willing-buyer basis, with prices commercially negotiated between producers and licensed refineries, taking prevailing international prices into account.

The provision does not automatically guarantee cheaper petrol for consumers, but it establishes a framework to ensure crude supply to operational domestic refineries.

Mr Abdullahi also challenged the argument that removing the fuel subsidy was necessary to address Nigeria’s financial difficulties.

Mr Fashola had recalled the financial challenges faced by the administration of former President Muhammadu Buhari, when debt servicing consumed a substantial proportion of government revenue.

He argued that the country’s inability to sustain the subsidy arrangement had made its removal necessary.

Trending