Connect with us

Special Reports

COP31: Nigerian, global groups accuse presidencies of risking ‘disappointing’ climate deal

Published

on

The coalition said the joint leadership of Türkiye and Australia had failed to provide sufficient direction during negotiations, allowing disagreements over climate finance, adaptation and the transition away from fossil fuels to weaken the expected outcome.

A coalition of 100 civil society organisations, including three Nigerian groups, has accused the COP31 presidencies of failing to demonstrate the leadership needed to secure an ambitious climate agreement, warning that the summit could become one of the most disappointing in the history of global climate negotiations.

The Nigerian organisations listed among the signatories are Environmental Rights Action, Health of Mother Earth Foundation (HOMEF) and Parents for Future Nigeria.

The coalition said the joint leadership of Türkiye and Australia failed to provide sufficient direction during negotiations, allowing disagreements over climate finance, adaptation and the transition away from fossil fuels to weaken the expected outcome.

The letter was issued as negotiations in Antalya extended beyond their scheduled 20 November conclusion, with countries still struggling to reach consensus on key elements of the final agreement.

A major concern raised by the organisations is the removal of explicit references to fossil fuels from the revised draft cover decision.

An earlier version of the text contained two formulations on transitioning away from fossil fuels, including language calling for accelerated action to phase them out. However, the references were removed in the subsequent draft released on 19 November.

The revised text retained provisions promoting carbon capture and carbon dioxide removal technologies, prompting concerns among environmental groups that the agreement could create room for continued fossil fuel production rather than prioritising emissions reductions.

The signatories described the draft as a gift to the fossil fuel industry, arguing that coal, oil and gas, the major drivers of the climate crisis, were no longer adequately addressed.

They also criticised the treatment of the proposed global electrification target, which seeks to increase electricity’s share of global final energy consumption from about 23 per cent to 35 per cent by 2035.

Although the target remains in the revised text, the organisations argued that it must be explicitly linked to renewable energy and the transition away from fossil fuels.

Without such safeguards, they warned, increased electricity consumption could still be powered by fossil fuels, leaving countries dependent on the energy sources responsible for worsening global warming.

The groups also questioned the prominence given to carbon capture, utilisation and storage (CCUS), calling for the removal of a quantified target for the technology from the draft agreement.

Beyond energy commitments, the organisations expressed concern over the weakening of provisions on climate finance, particularly funding for adaptation in developing countries.

The earlier draft included a proposed target of at least $120 billion annually in adaptation finance. However, the figure was removed from the revised text, leaving uncertainty over how the commitment to increase adaptation funding would be delivered.

The coalition accused developed countries of arriving at the negotiations without new financial commitments, arguing that the failure to provide adequate funding would leave vulnerable communities exposed to worsening climate impacts.

It called for an accountability mechanism for public climate finance obligations, including a delivery plan for the proposed $120 billion adaptation funding target.

The organisations also urged the presidencies to restore provisions recognising the distinct and collective rights of Indigenous Peoples, including their right to self-determination, free, prior and informed consent, and secure land tenure.

They further called for the final agreement to acknowledge the International Court of Justice’s advisory opinion on states’ obligations in addressing climate change, alongside a relevant United Nations General Assembly resolution.

The letter adds to mounting criticism of the negotiations, particularly following the removal of fossil fuel language from the draft agreement.

The disagreement reflects a wider divide between countries pushing for stronger commitments to move away from fossil fuels and those concerned about the economic and financial implications of such a transition.

The COP31 presidencies have defended the revised text, arguing that the negotiations must focus on securing an agreement that countries can collectively support rather than repeatedly restating existing commitments.

However, the signatories said the presidencies must use their remaining time to restore stronger provisions on climate finance, electrification, Indigenous rights and the transition away from fossil fuels.

They also urged Türkiye and Australia to work with Brazil’s COP30 presidency and Ethiopia, which will host COP32, to advance the roadmap for transitioning away from fossil fuels through a presidency-led dialogue outside the formal consensus process.

The organisations warned that without decisive action, Ethiopia could inherit unresolved disagreements and the responsibility of advancing commitments that COP31 had failed to secure.

The letter concluded by reminding the two presidencies that they had voluntarily taken on the responsibility of leading the negotiations and still had an opportunity to prevent the summit from ending without meaningful progress.

Trending