Special Reports
Supreme Court’s ₦11.7bn Scandal: ₦10.2bn Vouchers Unaccounted For As Seven Retired Justices Retain ₦515.8m Government Cars

Secrets Reporters
A sweeping government financial review has uncovered approximately ₦11.72 billion in questionable transactions involving the Supreme Court of Nigeria, including ₦10.22 billion in paid vouchers that could not be accounted for, government vehicles worth ₦515.86 million retained by retired Supreme Court Justices and an alleged contract overbilling of ₦11.43 million.
The findings, covering various financial transactions between January 2017 and December 2020, have exposed several administrative and financial irregularities within Nigeria’s apex court. The issues identified include missing payment records, the retention of government-owned assets by retired judicial officers and discrepancies in the computation of contract costs.
The period under review spans the tenures of two former Chief Justices of Nigeria, Justice Walter Onnoghen and Justice Ibrahim Tanko Muhammad. Onnoghen assumed office in March 2017 and remained in the position until his resignation in 2019, following his conviction by the Code of Conduct Tribunal over false asset declaration. Muhammad subsequently served as Chief Justice from January 2019 until his resignation in June 2022.
One of the most significant findings in the financial review concerns ₦10,220,000,000 in payment vouchers reportedly processed and paid by the Supreme Court but which investigators could not account for through the records examined.
The amount represents the largest item among seven separate issues identified in the relevant section of the review, with the total value of the flagged transactions reaching approximately ₦11,720,152,304.11.
The inability to account for the vouchers raises questions about the documentation supporting the expenditure and the procedures used to verify payments made from public funds. The review’s findings point to a significant gap in the court’s financial accountability records, particularly regarding the availability of supporting documents for transactions already recorded as paid.
Another major finding concerns the procurement and allocation of official vehicles to Supreme Court Justices, with investigators identifying 18 vehicles valued at ₦515,858,000.00 that were retained by seven Justices after their retirement.
According to the review, the Supreme Court spent ₦3,345,137,180.00 on the purchase of 45 vehicles between 2017 and 2021. However, 18 of the vehicles, valued at more than half a billion naira, were attached to seven retiring Justices who reportedly retained them after leaving the bench.
Investigators found no evidence that the vehicles had been formally auctioned to the retired Justices or that proceeds from any such sales had been paid into government accounts.
The absence of auction documentation and evidence of remittance meant that the court could not establish that the transfer of ownership had followed the required government procedures. The vehicles, therefore, remained a subject of concern in the review because they were public assets whose disposal was expected to be properly documented.
The review identified the practice as contrary to Establishment Circular SGF.19/S.52/V/720, issued on February 20, 2017, as well as paragraphs 112(i) and 2614 of the Financial Regulations 2009.
When confronted with the observation, the Supreme Court’s management explained that the vehicles were part of the entitlements of Supreme Court Justices.
The response stated: “The vehicles are part of Supreme Court Justices’ entitlement.”
However, the explanation did not provide evidence of formal auctions or payment of proceeds into government coffers. Investigators identified the potential loss of government assets and the diversion of public property for private use as the major risks associated with the transaction.
The financial review also uncovered a separate contract irregularity involving ₦11,433,600.00, which investigators identified as an overbilling arising from the computation of a contract awarded by the Supreme Court in 2019.
The contract was awarded on September 26, 2019, during the tenure of former Chief Justice Ibrahim Tanko Muhammad, at an original value of ₦86,632,035.00. It subsequently attracted the attention of financial examiners, who reviewed the Bill of Quantities to determine whether the contract amount was correctly calculated.
Following a recomputation of the Bill of Quantities, the examiners identified a discrepancy of ₦11,433,600.00, representing the amount by which the contract was allegedly inflated.
The review cited violations of Section 31(3) of the Public Procurement Act and paragraph 708 of the Financial Regulations 2009. These provisions establish requirements relating to public procurement procedures, financial accountability and the proper assessment of government contract costs.
Investigators identified the inflated amount as a potential loss of public funds, warning that the discrepancy could represent an unnecessary expenditure arising from the overstatement of the contract value.
Unlike the vehicle transaction, where management provided an explanation based on the entitlement of retiring Justices, the Supreme Court’s management reportedly failed to respond to the query raised over the ₦11,433,600.00 contract discrepancy.
The absence of a management response left the observation unresolved in the review, with no explanation provided to address the recomputation findings or justify the difference identified by the financial examiners.
The report’s recommendations concerning the broader financial findings were formally addressed to the Chief Registrar of the Supreme Court, who serves as the court’s chief administrative and accounting officer. The recommendations were not directly addressed to either of the former Chief Justices.
Although the period covered by the review overlaps with the tenures of Onnoghen and Tanko Muhammad, the findings presented do not, by themselves, establish that either former Chief Justice personally authorised, participated in or benefited from the specific administrative and financial irregularities identified.
Separately, Peoples Gazette reported allegations in 2022 that former Chief Justice Tanko Muhammad diverted judiciary budgetary allocations and denied Supreme Court Justices basic working tools. Those allegations are distinct from the financial review findings and should not be treated as established facts arising from the transactions examined in the report.
The combined findings place several aspects of the Supreme Court’s financial administration under scrutiny, particularly the management of payment vouchers, the disposal of government assets and the verification of contract costs before public funds are committed.
With ₦10.22 billion in paid vouchers remaining unaccounted for, ₦515.86 million worth of vehicles retained by seven retired Justices without evidence of formal auction and an additional ₦11.43 million identified as contract overbilling, the financial review has brought the total value of the highlighted transactions into sharp focus.
The responsibility for addressing the administrative observations and implementing the recommendations rests with the relevant offices, particularly the Chief Registrar’s office, to which the review formally directed its recommendations. As presented in the findings, the documentation gaps, vehicle transfers and contract computation discrepancies remain issues requiring clarification and appropriate accounting records.
Follow Secrets Reporters on WhatsApp: join the channel for every exclusive the moment it publishes.

Investigations5 days agoOPay in Trouble as CBN and Others Slam Fintech With ₦946m in Fines Over Money Laundering and Other Breaches
News6 days agoOPay faces CBN sanction, fined ₦994m for Money laundering, Terrorism Financing amid US IPO Setback
Investigations5 days agoExclusive: Stanbic IBTC Group CEO Nwokocha secures ₦1.36bn home loans from group’s bank seven weeks after appointment, holds zero shares
Special Reports3 days ago“₦250m Went To Meristem, ₦100m To Ladoja” — Bank Manager Tells Court ONSA Paid Real Properties Investment Limited Under Dasuki
Special Reports6 days agoJUST IN: Gov Sanwo-Olu rewards Flamingos with ₦300 million, iPhones
News5 days agoExclusive: Ogun/Osun River Basin Authority under Ashiru paid ₦32bn in two years, ₦7.08bn went to 11 inactive companies, records reveal
News5 days agoExclusive: NPHCDA under Faisal Shuaib spent only 31% of ₦7.29bn COVID-19 allocation as ₦2.24bn audit remains unfinished and unpublished
Top Stories6 days ago“₦10 Million Each” — Sanwo-Olu Announces ₦300m Reward, iPhones For Flamingos After Historic World Cup Victory















